• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

HIE Help Center

  • About HIE
    • Definition
    • Prevalence
    • Types
    • Causes & Risk Factors
    • Associated Conditions
    • Long-Term Outcomes
    • Life Expectancy
  • Identifying HIE
    • Signs and Symptoms
    • Exams & Tests
    • Developmental Delays
  • Prevention
    • Prenatal Testing
    • Proper Medical Care
    • Preventing Premature Birth
    • Betamethasone
    • Magnesium Sulfate
    • Fetal Heart Monitoring
    • C-Section Delivery
  • Treatment
    • Hypothermia Therapy
    • Assistive Technology
    • Service Animals
    • Medications
    • Surgical Interventions
    • Physical Therapy
    • Occupational Therapy
    • Speech Language Pathology
    • Recreational Therapy
    • Behavioral & Emotional Therapy
    • Massage Therapy
    • Sensory Integration Therapy
    • Stem Cell Therapy
    • Complementary Therapy
  • Care
    • Care Considerations
    • Caregiver Support
    • Types of Care
  • Education
    • Early Intervention
    • Special Education & IEPs
    • IEPs During Transitions
    • Transition to Adulthood
  • Finances
    • Cash Assistance
    • Basic Needs
    • Legal Options
    • Accounts & Trusts
    • Tax Planning
    • Cerebral Palsy Cost Guide
  • Legal
    • Choosing An Attorney
  • Español
  • HIE Resources
    • Glossary
    • Disability Rights & Laws
    • Scholarship
    • Multimedia
    • Downloadables
    • Disability Awareness Class Lessons
    • Disability Events
    • Helpful Links
  • Blog
  • Community
    • Scholarship Essay Gallery
  • Contact
Smiling Baby

Call Us : 888-329-0122

Home / Disability / Standing Wheelchairs Improve Users’ Health and Independence. So Why Won’t Insurance Agencies Cover Them?
Standing Wheelchairs & Insurance
Standing Wheelchairs Improve Users’ Health and Independence. So Why Won’t Insurance Agencies Cover Them?

Standing Wheelchairs Improve Users’ Health and Independence. So Why Won’t Insurance Agencies Cover Them?

Too much time spent sitting can put people at risk for a wide array of health conditions (1, 2). For many, the solution is simple: sit less, and stand and move around more.

Standing Wheelchairs & Insurance

Of course, it is more complicated for people who use wheelchairs: even those who use manual wheelchairs and do substantial aerobic exercise and upper-body strength training may experience certain negative effects of excessive sitting. For example, they may develop digestive problems due to pressure on internal organs.

One way for wheelchair users to avoid problems associated with continuous sitting is to use “standing wheelchairs.” Some permit wheeled movement while standing or sitting; others can only be moved while the user is sitting, but can raise the user into an upright, stationary position. Like their ‘traditional’ counterparts, standing wheelchairs are available in both manual and power-operated forms.

There are substantial benefits associated with using this type of equipment. These were made clear by the Rehabilitation Engineering and Assistive Technology Society of North America (RESNA) in their publication “RESNA Position on the Application of Wheelchair Standing Devices.” They argue that standing wheelchairs and similar devices improve physical well-being. This is backed up by many health measurements, including:

  • Breathing ability
  • Digestion
  • Bladder function
  • Blood circulation
  • Muscle tone
  • Bone mineral density
  • Skeletal structure
  • Incidence of pressure sores (3)

Moreover, standing wheelchairs give users greater independence when it comes to doing day-to-day activities. For those who don’t live in modified homes, this can be drastically life-altering. For those who do, it can still make it much easier to navigate work, travel, etc.

The ability to engage with others at eye-level also has a lot of social benefits. As Lucy Webster writes in an opinion piece published by the Guardian, “Yes, of course [having a standing wheelchair] means that I can reach things on shelves and whatnot. But it also means I can do typical twentysomething activities such as introduce myself in a noisy environment or even, God forbid, sit at a bar” (4).

Considering how much standing wheelchairs can improve users’ physical health, independence, and social life, it is not hugely surprising that RESNA also found an increase in psychological well-being.

For all their benefits, standing wheelchairs come with a pretty hefty cost: high-quality powered standing wheelchairs are upwards of $50,000. Manual options are less expensive, but still sell for thousands of dollars (5).

Frustratingly, Medicare, Medicaid, and private insurance companies often refuse to cover standing wheelchairs. They may argue that this type of equipment is not medically necessary, too experimental, or a convenience item. Considering the research, however, these claims seem unsubstantiated. Data supporting the health benefits of standing wheelchairs (as well as the costs of not having one) abounds, and this equipment has certainly surpassed the experimental phase. The response that standing wheelchairs are a “convenience” item sometimes goes along with the suggestion that people instead just transfer out of a seated wheelchair and into a stationary stander for a portion of the day (6). Unless people are going to bring both types of equipment with them everywhere, this would probably mean a short period of standing once or twice a day, perhaps less often for those who need assistance transferring from one device to the other. Research shows that it is best to stand periodically throughout the day, and that time spent standing should add up to about four hours a day (7). The ideal duration and frequency of standing may vary from person to person, but should be determined by individual ability/comfort level and the advice of medical professionals, and not by a lack of access to adaptive equipment like standing wheelchairs.

In her op-ed, Webster writes, “For some disabled people, our wheelchairs are the substitute for our legs. Yet the way we treat disabled people is like asking someone who has broken both legs to pay for the operation to fix the second break – and this from a government that aims to get more of us in work, while remaining indifferent to helping us do so.”  She is referring to the U.K.’s national health system (NHS), but the same could be said of governmental programs in the U.S.

Some people have found ways to get the government to pay for their standing wheelchair. This may involve writing a very detailed letter explaining why this equipment will help to alleviate their specific health conditions (not just why it is generally useful), and backing it up with statements from their doctors and relevant research papers (6). Persistence helps. Some even contact congressional representatives (5). State-run programs may be easier to persuade than national ones.

Others seek assistance from VA hospitals, nonprofits, or religious organizations. They may also turn to crowdsourcing websites like GoFundMe.

It is of course a good thing that people are finding alternative ways to pay for standing wheelchairs, but they shouldn’t have to. In an ideal world, GoFundMe would be used for creative business startups and study abroad trips  –  not providing something so critically important to physical health, independence, and psychological well being. Governmental agencies and private insurance companies should recognize that this is within their jurisdiction.


Sources:

  1. Too much sitting: The Population-Health Science of Sedentary Behavior
  2. Sitting Can Increase Your Risk of Cancer By Up to 66%
  3. RESNA Position on the Application of Wheelchair Standing Devices
  4. Wheelchairs have come a long way  –  shame the NHS hasn’t
  5. Stand Up and Go with Mobile Standers and Standing Wheelchairs
  6. Justify It: Standing Frames and Wheelchairs
  7. The sedentary office: a growing case for change towards better health and productivity.
Download this page as PDF

Filed Under: Disability, Finance, Insurance, and Care Planning Tagged With: advocacy, assistive equipment, disability, Technology

Comments

  1. Darwin Hurd says

    August 24, 2019 at 6:40 pm

    Been trying to get a stand up wheelchair for 19 years. Now I have a very bad 2 inch deep pressure sore on my backside. why can’t I get any help?

    Log in to Reply
    • rstokes says

      August 26, 2019 at 2:46 pm

      Hello, we will respond to your comment via email soon.

      Log in to Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Talk With Us

About

The HIE Help Center serves as an informational resource guide for families of children with hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy (HIE). It is sponsored by ABC Law Centers, a birth trauma law firm that has represented families of children with HIE and other birth injuries for over 20 years.

Contact

HIE Help Center
Owned by ABC Law Centers & Jesse Reiter
122 Concord Rd
Bloomfield Hills, MI 48304

Follow Us

Follow us on Facebook
Follow us on Twitter
Pinterest

Copyright © 2017 HIE Help Center. All Rights Reserved. Attorney Advertising – Disclaimers | Privacy Policy | Sitemap | About the HIE Help Center